What is the difference between Brazilian
jiu-jitsu and Japanese Jujitsu (Jujutsu)?
The first and most important reason can be found in the art's history
and is primary to all others discussed afterward. When you research
the history of Brazilian Jiu-jitsu, you will understand that it came
from "Judo" in its time of renaissance. In the early 1900's, Judo was
being developed from a variety of Jiu-jitsu styles in order to make it
the most complete and effective martial art in the world. Some older
Jiu-jitsu schools only focused on one area of fighting (some practiced
primarily standing techniques) and had been left without a realistic
battlefield testing ground for hundreds of years. If you recall the
history of Judo's beginning, you know that it was made up of mostly
standing techniques at first, from Kito Ryu Jiu-jitsu and a few other
styles. This alone was not enough, so the groundwork of Fusen Ryu was
added, making it more complete. When you say "traditional" or
"Japanese" Jiu-jitsu, you are referring to only one of these Jiu-jitsu
styles, which is incomplete alone. When you say Brazilian Jiu-jitsu,
you are referring to the best techniques from a wide variety of
styles.
Our Jiu-Jitsu in the United States was underdeveloped compared to the
Jiu-Jitsu in Brazil. Only now are we beginning to catch up, and we
are still suffering from the inadequacies of the 'older' and more
traditional schools of Jiu-Jitsu in this country. To give you an idea
of what I mean, I'll tell you a little about my training. I earned a
black belt in a classical style of Jiu-Jitsu, which taught all the
Judo throws of the Kodokan and Aikijitsu (the grandfather of Aikido).
It was a great art, but one that could not be used on anyone with
skill effectively before complete mastery. I was subsequently
defeated by a student of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu who was only at blue belt
level, while I was a black belt in traditional Jiu-Jitsu. Why? Lack
of realistic practice is the reason. There was too much of: "you stay
perfectly still while I try an extravagant technique on you and you
play along." There are many techniques which is where Judo is great,
and some traditional schools teach techniques that were designed
thousands of years ago whose applications have not been modified or
thought about since. Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu is simple to learn, so
simple that a dedicated student of one year can easily beat martial
artists of other styles who have many years of experience.
Some styles of martial arts spend hundreds of hours working on a rigid
stance and one hundred standing techniques that cannot possibly be
mastered in a reasonable amount of time. I once interviewed Royce
Gracie and he gave a response that supports this point quite well: